Managers and generative AI: judgement weakened or strengthened depending on use

Patrick Haack, Professor of Strategy and Responsible Management at HEC Lausanne (UNIL), and his colleagues from the Universities of Bath, Ohio and Cardiff have developed a theoretical model of “managerial phronesis”, the practical wisdom that managers develop through human interaction, real-world experience and reflection. Published in the Academy of Management Review, the model identifies the organisational and technological conditions under which generative AI helps managers make thoughtful decisions, and those under which it may lead them to over-rely on algorithmic recommendations and gradually lose important judgement capabilities.

For Patrick Haack, generative AI chatbots can result in either deskilling or upskilling, depending on how managers incorporate them into their work practices and how organisations support their use. The risk particularly concerns junior managers who, by delegating much of their decision-making to AI, would lack an experiential base of learning. The main conclusion: organisations need to create spaces where managers and employees can continue to experiment and learn from real-life experiences. Managers must also always remain accountable for their decisions, with or without AI.

https://www.unil.ch/news/1793096653571